Asphalt vs Tar and Chip: Comprehensive Guide to Choose the Right Material For Your Driveway

Introduction

When it comes to getting that perfect driveway down, the choice of material is not just a practical decision but also a design statement. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare asphalt and tar and chip driveways, going into their characteristics, costs, and maintenance needs. Our aim with this short guide is to provide you with all the necessary information you need to make the best choice for your home, balancing aesthetics, budget, and longevity.

Section 1: Understanding the Basics

[foogallery id=”337″]

1.1 What is an Asphalt Driveway?

An asphalt driveway, which you’ll almost certainly seen around you in residential areas, is composed of a mixture of aggregate (like sand and stone) and asphalt cement. This mix is heated and poured over a prepared base, creating a strong, durable and versatile surface. On top of this, asphalt’s naturally black colour absorbs heat and aids in melting snow and ice – helpful for those cold snaps.

1.2 What is a Tar and Chip Driveway?

Although similar in many ways, a tar and chip driveway, also known as chip-and-seal or macadam, offers a more textured surface. This method involves laying hot tar over a foundation – usually an existing driveway, path, or car park, etc – and then embedding stone chips into it. The result is a more natural-looking driveway with some more bespoke options when it comes to stone and colour choices.

Section 2: Comparing Asphalt and Tar and Chip Driveways

2.1 Asphalt vs Tar and Chip: Key Differences

The key distinctions between these two lie in their installation and aesthetic appeal. Asphalt requires a more involved installation process, including proper foundation and layering, and results in a uniform, smooth surface. Tar and chip, while simpler to install, provide a unique appearance with each application due to the natural variation in stone chips, making it suitable for both domestic and industrial settings.

2.2 Tar and Chip vs Asphalt: Durability and Maintenance

Asphalt, while durable, demands regular maintenance like seal coating every two to five years and crack repairs. In contrast, tar and chip driveways require less maintenance but might need more frequent resurfacing, especially in high-traffic areas. Both surfaces handle different climates well, with tar and chip offering better traction in snowy conditions.

Section 3: Cost Analysis

3.1 Tar and Chip Driveway Cost: What to Expect

The cost-effectiveness of tar and chip driveways is a significant draw. They are generally more affordable, with prices influenced by the type of stone used and the driveway’s size. The ability to lay it over an existing driveway also reduces costs significantly.

[foogallery id=”540″]

Asphalt driveways, while more costly upfront, can be a worthwhile investment due to their longevity. The cost varies based on the thickness of the asphalt, the size of the driveway, and regional material costs. Despite higher initial expenses, its durability means fewer replacements over time.

Get exact costs and an expert consultation for your driveway.

Section 4: The Pros and Cons

4.1 The Advantages of Tar and Chip Driveways

  • Customisable Aesthetic: Choose from various stones for a unique look.
  • Better Traction: Ideal for sloped driveways or areas with ice and snow.
  • Natural Drainage: Less likely to have standing water issues.
  • Ease of Repair: Simple to fix and resurface when needed.

4.2 The Downsides of Tar and Chip Driveways

  • Limited Professional Availability: Not all contractors offer this option.
  • Variable Longevity: Life expectancy can be shorter in harsh climates.

4.3 The Benefits of Asphalt Driveways

  • Resilience: Withstands heavy traffic and extreme weather.
  • Seamless Repairs: Easy to patch and blend with the existing surface.
  • Improved Property Value: Generally more favoured in real estate.
  • Versatile Design: Suitable for both modern and traditional homes.

4.4 The Drawbacks of Asphalt Driveways

  • Heat Sensitivity: Prone to softening and rutting in hot weather.
  • Regular Upkeep: Sealcoating and crack filling are necessary to maintain full benefits.

Section 5: Can You Do It Yourself?

5.1 Can You Tar and Chip Your Own Driveway?

DIY enthusiasts might consider tar and chip, and it certainly is possible, but it requires precision, the right equipment, a fair bit of patience, and a decent amount of elbow grease. The process of evenly spreading hot tar and stones demands skill and can be messy and hazardous without proper handling.

[foogallery id=”541″]

5.2 DIY Tips for Asphalt Driveways

Asphalt installation typically demands professional equipment and expertise, especially for new driveways. However, minor repairs and maintenance like crack filling and seal coating are doable as DIY projects with the right tools and materials.

Don’t have the tools, time, or patience? Get in touch with us today to discuss your needs.